SITE RATING: 5/10
SITE REVIEW:
Originally
released on Premiere Records (XM-S1), and anonymously credited to Kurt
Von Baum and the Homburg (sic) Symphony, this department store
promotional album has been sonically cleaned up and reissued on CD-R
and mp3 format by ReDiscovery Music,
who also did a little detective work as well in order to discover the
original culprits. Based on their research, the identity of the
director is former Jersey City Philharmonic Symphony Orchestra
conductor J. Randolph Jones, who died in 1982 at the age of 72.
ReDiscovery Music has mastered this release from the original
reel tape masters, so it sounds excellent, probably better than the
original LP issue, but what about the performance? There's no
copywright date present on any of the LP sleeves, but I would guess by
the fidelity and style of performance that this recording hails from
the late-1960s/early 1970s, with little in the way of baroque stylings
evident, but tempos are generally quicker than those found in the 1950s
to mid-1960s. Everything is sung and played with great Victorian
vigor, and the unnamed choir sings with a ham-fisted emphasis that in
nevertheless unified and in tune - this isn't some thrown-together
group - perhaps, if this in fact the Jersey City Philharmonic Symphony,
a symphony chorus was used in the recording as well. The soloists are
similarly unnamed, which is probably for the best - the alto, soprano,
and tenor soloists acquit themselves well, if not with any particular
subtlety, but the bass soloist is far too "basso-profundo" for my
tastes. More a curiousity than an essential listen, I found the
mystery behind the recording of more interest than the recording itself.
|