SITE RATING: 8/10
SITE REVIEW:
Another
solid Messiah,
this one with an operatic flair, thanks to it's conductor, Sir Georg
Solti, and its stars, all of whom hail from the vaulted halls of
international opera. Thankfully, Sir Solti doesn't direct
Handel as if it were the second coming of Verdi, or Wagner's Der Ring des Nibelungen
- rather, he lets the music dance, in a very baroque manner, even if
the instrumentation is modern. Much like Neville Marriner's
1976
Messiah, this recording benefitted from the sure touch of a master's
hand, even if, as in Solti's case, the baroque era wasn't his forte.
That said, a great deal on how listeners enjoy this Messiah
depends on how well you tolerate operatic singing - baroque revivalist
interpretations tend to prefer clear, bell-like tones from their
sopranos and tenors, but Dame te Kanawa and Keith Lewis are from the
other side of the playground, giving gorgeously-hued, full-throated
tessaturas and vocal colors that veer far from current recordings, but
will be familiar to older audiences who grew up listening to Messiah on
long-playing records. One stickler for me about this disc,
(and
it's a nagging one) is that the arias and choruses are tied together
without any breaks between them, meaning that in order to hear a
favorite chorus, you often have to listen to the preceeding aria as well - which is completely
unnecessary in the digital age. But, if you're looking for a
first choice for a Messiah,
Solti isn't a bad choice; the playing is sure and passionate, the
singing is expert, if a little over-the-top, and the early digital
sound is surprisingly warm and full.
~ BDW
|