SITE RATING: 8/10
SITE REVIEW:
This privately-produced and released recording of Messiah
was performed by The Saint Thomas Church in the city and County of New
York, and is definitely worth seeking out for both casual and dedicated
collectors. Conductor John Scott has assembled an excellent
company, with soloists, chorus, and orchestra all in fine form.
Although lacking the sparkle and polish of a studio recording,
the passion and emotion of the work is on full display. Recorded
live in St. Thomas' church in December, 2006, there is the usual
distance in the recording typical of live settings, but this is easily
overlooked in the joyous tempos and splendid singing and playing.
I was impressed with bass Sumner Thompson's stirring arias, and
the bouncing ricocheting "Let us break their bonds" is captured in
brilliant display of the choir's virtuosity. Tenor Joseph Gaines
is a fiery, evangelical soloist, while soprano Ava Pine sounds a bit
too full-throated for her showpieces. Still, this is an excellent
recording, another fine example in the growing list of english-speaking
Mozart-arranged Messiahs.
|