SITE RATING: 1/10
SITE REVIEW:
Previously released in 1976 on the Everest label
(SDBR 3398), and originally credited to 'Soloist, Chorus and Chamber
Orchestra of the Pro
Musica Antiqua', label Metacom Inc. re-released this album crediting
the
choir and orchestra of St. Paul's Cathedral under the baton of Randolph
Jones. Madacy records has also released this album (again
credited to "Pro Antiqua") as part of its Ultimate Christmas Collection
box set, but regardless, it's the same recording. Whatever
guise
it appears in, it needs to be avoided, since the sound is abyssmal, the
performance is ham-handed, and the track order is completely random.
I suspect that this release was mastered from vinyl sources -
there is an underlying "buzz" in the recorded sound which sounds
throughout, as well as occassional distortion in the upper and lower
ranges. As to the performance, it's strictly
by-the-numbers: the chorus sound like a basic community choir
with
wide-spread vowels; the tenor soloist is cursed with a wobbly vibrato
in his otherwise boyish tone, the orchestra plays well, but with little
distinction, the alto soloist is similarly b-class; the bass soloist
combines all the worst qualities of throaty, heavy singing, and the
soprano occasionally slides up to her upper register.
Consider
this recording
one for the scrap heap.
|