SITE RATING: 4/10
SITE REVIEW:
This
2007 Canadian release by CBC Records doesn't have much out of the
ordinary to recommend it - one of the few English-language Mozart
arrangements to make to it disc, (and even rarer, a highlights disc) it
features competent performances that never rise above the ordinary.
Pedestrian direction (dual credited to Bruce Pullan for the
Vancouver Symphony Orchestra and Jon Washburn for the Vancouver Bach
Choir); competent, but plain singing by the choir, and soloists who
don't rise above the regional talents they're given. The soloists
are not named in the liner notes, but it's probably all for the best -
none of them have special qualities, and feature mostly brittle, shrill
tones (especially the tenor who sings consistently sharp), and since
this is the Mozart arrangement, the soloists are featured more
prominently, and their prominence drags the recording down a couple of
notches. The soprano and alto soloists have a bubbly bounce to
their melismas which had the unpleasant effect of sounding jittery -
rather than a rising ebb and flow of the line, it gave the effect of
"dotting all their 'i's" Overall, an indifferent performance that
most should be able to live without.
|