SITE RATING: 6/10
SITE REVIEW:
Marketed towards the new-age/gift-shop audience, this instrumental-only presentation of Handel's Messiah
rated somewhat higher with me than I would have assumed, but my
expectations were admittedly pretty low. Although performed on
synthesizers, great care has been taken to mimic the sound of actual
instruments, and the performance sounds as if it is indeed being
played, rather than simply programmed into existence. Producer
and performer James Pease begins the program with an improvisation on
the opening "Sinfony" - slowing down the main melodic line and
gradually building up steam towards an exciting climax. Although
the disc is split into only seven "parts" - each part is a suite of
arias and choruses subtly rearranged by Pease, so as to blend movements
together. As such, this is more than just quiet background music;
the music captures the original thrust and dancing motions of Handel's
original, and becomes an active listening experience. Thankfully,
James Pease seems to have a real affection for the original, which
translates into this adaption. I don't think that this disc will
replace anyone's top choice for a Messiah highlights disc, but as an alternative way of hearing Messiah,
it's better than some of the other alternatives which are out there.
Besides this "instrumental orchestration" edition, there is also
an alternate version, released by NatureQuest, which adds background
"Nature Sounds" to ...uh, enhance the experience. Or enhance the
cheese factor. Your call.
|