SITE RATING: 8/10
SITE REVIEW:
Richard Bonynge's 1969 Messiah
is curious for several reasons, not the least being the amount of
ornamentation encouraged by all the soloists; it's as if Vincenzo
Bellini had taken up his pen and tried re-arranging Messiah
in the same manner as Mozart. Certainly a different approach, and
one that is certain to engender discussion. From my point of
view, it's simply a different way of looking at Messiah, which is, if not always successful from an artistic point of view, is almost always interesting; since if Messiah
were simply carbon-copied from one peformance to the next, it would
wither and die. But there are some very good things evident in
this recording as well, from the bright, dancing tempos, to the
wondefully sensitive playing by the English Chamber Orchestra, to the
solid singing of the Ambrosian Chorus. The soloists, apart from
the unusually high amount of ornamentation, are also quite good, the
only large distraction being contralto Hughette Tourangeau's French
accent, which often flattens the English vowels. Joan Sutherland
is glorious - in her prime here, and singing with the lovely bell-like
tones which she built her formidable reputation upon. This is a
perfectly adequate Messiah, the only major sticking point being the
excessive ornamentation, but otherwise, beautifully performed, and a
high point of the 1960s Messiah cycles.
|